Renewal letters for 2027 are landing now, and most of them carry bad news. In Marsh’s 2026 survey of more than 1,800 U.S. employers, total health benefit cost per employee is projected to rise 8.2% in 2027, the biggest jump since 2003, and 11% for employers that don’t make changes.
For a building contractor or construction company with 20 to 150 employees, that kind of increase rarely arrives evenly. One rough claims year, one surgery, one premature baby, and the next renewal can come in at 20% or more. The fix many Texas construction companies are turning to has an unglamorous name: block underwriting.
Key Takeaways (TL;DR)
- Block underwriting rates your company as part of a large pool of association members instead of on your claims alone.
- A bigger pool means one bad year at one company has less pull on its renewal.
- ABS association plan renewals have averaged about 3 to 3.5% over the last five years. Results vary by group.
- Membership required: you need to be an AGC of Texas or PHCC of Texas member to join the association plans, and an employee census is usually all it takes to get firm rates.
What Is Block Underwriting?
In a standard small-group plan, the carrier prices your company as a stand-alone risk. Your employees’ ages and your claims history drive your rate, so a small group’s renewal can swing hard from one year to the next.
Block underwriting works differently. Through the AGC Plan and the PHCC Plan, member companies are rated together as one large block. The carrier looks at the whole pool, thousands of Texas construction employees, rather than your 40 people in isolation. Large claims still matter, but they’re spread across the block instead of landing on one company’s renewal.
Why Small Construction Companies Feel Renewals the Hardest
Construction workforces are physical, spread across age ranges, and often smaller than 100 people. That’s exactly the profile where a single large claim moves the needle. It’s also why so many owners end up in what Brian Stevenson calls “the dance”: the same four carriers, a big increase, a switch, and the same thing again two years later.
Switching carriers every couple of years has its own costs. Employees change networks and ID cards, deductibles reset, and someone in the office loses a week to paperwork. Some companies look at level-funded plans or stop-loss coverage to get off that cycle. Block underwriting is another way, and for many association members it’s the simplest.
What It Looks Like in Practice
- A 90-employee Texas electrical contracting company moved to the AGC Program, saved about $70,000, and came through its first renewal at 3%.
- A 30-employee Texas general contracting company left the carrier it had used for 10 years, got better benefits, and saved more than $50,000 a year.
- Across the association plans, relatively healthy groups have averaged about 20% savings in year one, and renewals have averaged about 3 to 3.5% over the last five years.
Results vary by group, and not every company will see the same numbers. The point is the pattern: steadier renewals and fewer forced carrier changes.
Is an Association Plan Right for Your Company?
It’s worth a look if:
- You’re an AGC of Texas or PHCC of Texas member, or would join to get access.
- Your renewals have bounced between small and painful increases.
- You’ve switched carriers more than once in the last five years.
- You’re quoting the same few carriers every year.
ABS still quotes the open market too: 12 to 13 carriers for group health insurance, plus the association plans. If the association plan isn’t the best fit, you’ll see that side by side.
What to Do Before You Sign Your 2027 Renewal
- Pull your current census: employee names, dates of birth, zip codes and coverage tiers.
- Get your renewal and current plan summary in one place.
- Compare more than four carriers, including at least one association option.
- Ask what happens at the following renewal, not just this one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does block underwriting mean in health insurance?
It means your company is rated as part of a larger group of companies, here the members of an association plan, instead of on your own claims history alone.
Do I have to be an AGC or PHCC member?
Yes, the association plans are a member benefit. ABS can also quote the open market for companies that aren’t members.
What do you need to give firm rates?
Usually just an employee census. The free Plan Rater is a quick way to start.
Does ABS charge extra for HR help?
No. ABS clients get COBRA administration, ACA 1095 reporting, eligibility and compliance support, and employee handbook help at no extra cost.
See Where Your Plan Stands
Before you sign your renewal, rate your current plan free with the ABS Plan Rater, or call Brian Stevenson at (281) 673-4289. Association Benefit Solutions has served Texas building contractors and construction companies since 1978.
Ready to Compare Your Plan?
Find out in about four minutes whether you’re overpaying for employee benefits. Use our free Plan Rater, or talk with Brian Stevenson and the ABS team about your renewal. We’ve served Texas building contractors and construction companies since 1978.





